71 BAY AVE, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

71 BAY AVE, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

71 BAY AVE is a Residential (4 Families or less) property with 656 sq/ft of space. Taxes are $5,678 annually. This property was built in 1948 and is owned by JERSEY STRONG PROPERTIES, LLC who lives at 406 14TH AVE. This property was last sold on 2025-12-02 for $208,000. This property is valued at $317 per sq/ft based on sales price. This property is valued at $601 per sq/ft based on total assessment. This property is zoned R-5, The building description is 1SF and land description is 50X120.

Block	Lot	Qual
69	46
Owner	Owner Address	Owner City/State/Zip
JERSEY STRONG PROPERTIES, LLC	406 14TH AVE	BELMAR, NJ 07719
Property Class	Square Ft	Year Built
2 - Residential (4 Families or less)	656	1948

Last Sold
71 BAY AVE, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

Year Sold	Sales Price
2025-12-02	$208,000

Assessments
71 BAY AVE, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

Year	Owner	Land Assessment	Building Assessment	Total Assessment	Exemption	Assessed
2026	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$269,000	$125,400	$394,400	$0	$394,400
2025	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$227,500	$124,300	$351,800	$0	$351,800
2024	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$175,800	$122,000	$297,800	$0	$297,800
2023	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$168,300	$84,800	$253,100	$0	$253,100
2022	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$147,000	$80,800	$227,800	$0	$227,800
2021	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$125,500	$70,600	$196,100	$0	$196,100
2020	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$107,300	$69,000	$176,300	$0	$176,300
2019	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$106,200	$68,600	$174,800	$0	$174,800
2018	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$92,400	$65,400	$157,800	$0	$157,800
2017	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$80,000	$63,400	$143,400	$0	$143,400
2016	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$77,000	$64,700	$141,700	$0	$141,700
2015	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$77,000	$64,500	$141,500	$0	$141,500
2014	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$102,000	$59,000	$161,000	$0	$161,000
2013	DWYER, TIMOTHY	$102,000	$59,000	$161,000	$0	$161,000

Properties Near
71 BAY AVE, MIDDLETOWN, NJ

Street Address	Owner	Block	Lot	Qual	Class
58 BAY AVE	HANDEL, WILLIAM F & VARGAS, JEANINE	69	35		2
60 BAY AVE	SMITH, HEATHER	69	36		2
60 BAY AVE	PRESTON, RAYMOND	69	36		15F
63 BAY AVE	CONNOR, JAMES T & KAITLIN D	69	48		2
64 BAY AVE	SARNO, MICHELE & VICTOR	69	37		2
66 BAY AVE	VILLARINIS, GILBERTO & MELISSA	69	38		2
67 BAY AVE	BURLEW, RUSSELL JR	69	47		2
70 BAY AVE	COOPER, GRACE ELIZABETH & RUTH ANN	69	39		2
74 BAY AVE	MAGLIONE, PATRICIA A	69	40		2
75 BAY AVE	MERCURE, KENNETH A	69	45		2
76 BAY AVE	HODGKISS, WILLIAM F&PATRICIA L,ETAL	69	41		2
78 BAY AVE	SARPOLIS, SCOTT & DENISE	69	42		2
79 BAY AVE	DELOUISA, JARED M & RAYMUNDO-SANCHE	69	44		2

The property-related information for 71 BAY AVE, MIDDLETOWN, NJ displayed on this page is obtained from public records from MIDDLETOWN, NJ and other sources. While such information is thought to be reliable, it is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. njtaxrecords.net makes no warranties or representations whatsoever regarding the quality, content, completeness, accuracy or adequacy of such information and data. We last updated our database for 71 BAY AVE, MIDDLETOWN, NJ from public sources on 2026-01-17 06:05:40 UTC.